top of page
Search

The Real Credit Score Dystopia: Unmasking Propaganda and Examining Our Own Reality.

For years, Americans have been fed a steady diet of propaganda about China’s so-called "social credit system." The narrative painted an Orwellian picture of a nation where individuals’ daily lives were controlled by a centralized system, determining their ability to travel, purchase, or even exist in society. But recent revelations have turned this narrative on its head.


Apps like RedNote and firsthand accounts from Chinese citizens have uncovered a glaring truth: the widely publicized "social credit system" as it’s been portrayed does not actually exist. Instead, it turns out much of this story was built on misrepresentations and exaggerations—a convenient boogeyman to distract us from the very real, very systemic credit system we live under here in America.


Let’s take a step back and hold a mirror up to ourselves.


The Credit Score Reality We Ignore

While we’ve been pointing fingers at China for allegedly implementing a social credit system, the truth is that we are living in one of the most deeply entrenched credit-based societies in the world. In the United States, your credit score determines your ability to buy a home, purchase a car, or access financial resources. It's not just about access either—the system penalizes those with lower scores by forcing them to accept outrageous interest rates, making it even harder to climb out of debt.


This isn't some abstract fear—it’s everyday life for millions of Americans. A bad credit score can effectively cut people out of basic opportunities, perpetuating cycles of poverty and financial instability. And the kicker? The factors that influence your credit score are often opaque, riddled with bias, and heavily favor those already financially privileged.


The Propaganda Machine

So why were we told this story about China? Propaganda often serves as a tool to redirect attention away from our own shortcomings. The narrative about China’s “social credit system” served as a way to demonize a global competitor while distracting us from our own credit dystopia.


Instead of acknowledging how predatory lenders and financial institutions in the U.S. have rigged the system against the average citizen, the spotlight was placed on an exaggerated foreign threat. It’s classic misdirection—keep the public focused on the "other" while avoiding uncomfortable truths at home.


The Double Standard

Imagine trying to explain to someone outside the U.S. that, without a good credit score, you might:

  • Be denied a loan for your first home.

  • Be forced to pay higher insurance premiums.

  • Lose access to certain jobs that require credit checks.

  • Be stuck paying higher interest rates for necessities like cars or student loans.


It’s a system that punishes you for being poor, unstable, or simply for not understanding the arbitrary rules of the game.


Now imagine turning around and criticizing another country for allegedly having a system that tracks and ranks its citizens. The hypocrisy is glaring.


Breaking the Illusion

It’s time we stopped focusing on fabricated fears and started addressing the real systems that control us. The credit score system in America is designed to benefit the wealthy, exploit the poor, and perpetuate inequality. It’s a system that needs reform—not just for the sake of fairness but for the future of economic mobility and opportunity in this country.


Instead of wagging a finger at China, we should be asking ourselves hard questions:


  • Why is our financial system so dependent on credit scores that disproportionately harm marginalized groups?

  • How can we build alternative models of financial fairness and equity?

  • What would it take to unrig a system designed to keep people in cycles of debt?


The myth of China’s "social credit system" has served its purpose: distraction. But the truth about America’s credit score reality is far scarier because it’s not a myth—it’s the world we live in every day.


It’s time to stop looking at others and start holding ourselves accountable. Only then can we truly address the systems that oppress us. Let’s expose the hypocrisy, challenge the narrative, and fight for real change. The dystopia isn’t “over there.” It’s right here.

 
 
 

Commentaires


bottom of page